Back to Blog
Auto Train vs. Car Shipping vs. Driving to Florida: Snowbird Cost Comparison
Auto Train vs car shippingship car to Floridasnowbird car shippingdrive or ship car to FloridaAmtrak Auto Train alternative

Auto Train vs. Car Shipping vs. Driving to Florida: Snowbird Cost Comparison

Heading to Florida for the winter? Compare the Amtrak Auto Train, car shipping and driving I-95 by cost, time and effort, and find the best way to get your car south this season.

Updated November 22, 2026
8 min read

Every snowbird faces the same question each fall: how do I get my car to Florida? There are three main options. You can drive it down I-95 yourself, put it on the Amtrak Auto Train, or have it shipped on a car carrier while you fly.

Each one works, but they are very different in cost, time and effort. This guide compares all three side by side so you can choose what fits your budget, your schedule and how much driving you want to do this winter. If you want to see what shipping would cost for your exact route, you can get an instant car shipping quote to Florida in under a minute.

Quick Comparison

Auto Train vs car shipping vs driving to Florida compared by cost, time and effort

The figures below are typical estimates for one sedan going from the New York City area to South Florida, about 1,280 miles. Your numbers will depend on your cities, your vehicle, fuel prices and your travel dates.

Drive I-95Amtrak Auto TrainCar Shipping + Flight
Your time on the road2 to 3 daysAbout 4 hours to Lorton, VA, an overnight train, then about 4 hours from Sanford to South FloridaA few hours (a flight)
Typical costAbout $450 to $800 in fuel, hotels, meals and tollsVaries widely by date and seat or room typeAbout $900 to $1,600 for open transport, plus your flight
Driving requiredAbout 20 hoursAbout 8 hours, split across two short drivesNone
FlexibilityLeave any dayFixed schedule, one daily train each wayPick your week; pickup within a window
Best forCouples on a budget who enjoy the driveTravelers within easy reach of Northern VirginiaAnyone who wants to skip the drive entirely

Option 1: Driving to Florida Yourself

Driving is the classic snowbird trip. From New York City to Miami it is about 1,280 miles and roughly 20 hours behind the wheel, which most people split into 2 or 3 days.

What driving really costs

  • Fuel: at about 28 miles per gallon and $3.00 to $3.50 per gallon, roughly $140 to $170.
  • Hotels: 1 or 2 nights, often $120 to $200 per night along I-95.
  • Meals and snacks: about $60 to $120 per person for the trip.
  • Tolls: the New Jersey Turnpike, Delaware, Maryland and Florida's Turnpike can add $40 to $100 depending on your route.
  • Wear and tear: about 1,300 miles of tire wear, an oil change sooner, and added mileage on the car.

That puts a typical drive at about $450 to $800 in direct costs for two people, before counting your time and the miles on the car.

Pros and cons

Driving is usually the cheapest option in cash for a couple, and you can stop wherever you like. The downsides are real, though: long days on one of the busiest highways in the country, holiday traffic, and the chance of snow and ice in the first few hundred miles. For many retirees, three days of driving is the part of the trip they enjoy least.

Option 2: The Amtrak Auto Train

The Auto Train is a unique service that carries both you and your car between Lorton, Virginia (near Washington, D.C.) and Sanford, Florida (near Orlando). It runs once a day in each direction. You board in the afternoon, ride overnight, and pick up your car the next morning. The rail trip covers about 855 miles.

What to know before you book

  • You still have to drive both ends. From New York City, Lorton is about 4 hours away. From Sanford, Miami is about another 230 miles, roughly 4 hours. Naples and Fort Myers are a similar drive.
  • Fares change with demand. You pay for the vehicle plus each passenger, and sleeping rooms cost extra. Peak snowbird dates in November, December and January are usually the most expensive. Check current fares on Amtrak's website for your exact dates.
  • It has a fixed schedule. You need to arrive at Lorton well before departure to check in your car, and cars are unloaded in Sanford in the morning, so plan for some waiting.
  • It only covers one corridor. It does not help snowbirds heading to Arizona, Texas or the Gulf Coast.

Pros and cons

The Auto Train cuts out the long middle stretch of I-95 and lets you sleep through it. It is a good fit if you live within a few hours of Northern Virginia and your Florida home is in Central Florida. It is less convenient if you live in New England or the Midwest, or if your winter home is far from Sanford.

Option 3: Ship Your Car and Fly

With car shipping, a carrier picks your car up at or near your home and delivers it to your winter address. You fly down whenever you like, often on a short nonstop flight, and the car is waiting for you.

What shipping costs

For a standard sedan on an open carrier, New York to South Florida usually runs about $900 to $1,600, depending on your exact cities, your vehicle and the week you ship. Enclosed transport, a good choice for classics and luxury cars, typically costs about 40% to 60% more. Add the cost of your flight, which varies by airline and date.

Transit usually takes about 3 to 5 days after pickup, with a pickup window of 1 to 5 business days. Many snowbirds hand the car over a few days before they fly, so it arrives around the same time they do. Our snowbird car shipping guide covers prices on other popular routes, including the Midwest to Florida and Arizona.

Pros and cons

Shipping is the least effort by far: no long drive, no hotels, no winter roads, and no extra miles on your car. It works from any starting point to any Florida town, not just one rail corridor. It usually costs more than driving yourself, and you need someone to release and receive the car if you are not there for pickup or delivery.

Which Option Is Right for You?

  • Choose driving if you are traveling as a couple, you enjoy road trips, you are comfortable with long days behind the wheel, and keeping cash costs low matters most.
  • Choose the Auto Train if you live within a few hours of Lorton, Virginia, your winter home is in Central Florida, and you like the idea of sleeping through the drive.
  • Choose car shipping if you would rather fly, you are traveling alone, you are heading somewhere far from the Auto Train route, you have health or mobility concerns, or you simply do not want to drive I-95 in winter.

The hidden costs people forget

When you compare, count more than the ticket price. Driving puts about 2,600 round-trip miles on your car each season, which adds up over the years in tires, maintenance and resale value. It also costs you 2 to 3 days each way. For many snowbirds, especially those traveling alone, shipping comes out closer in total cost than it first looks.

Tips if You Decide to Ship

  • Book early. Mid-November to mid-December and the first week of January are the busiest weeks for southbound trucks. Book 2 to 4 weeks ahead.
  • Ship before you fly. Handing the car over a few days before your flight means it arrives about when you do.
  • Plan for gated communities. A full-size car carrier may not fit inside your condo complex. Agree on a nearby meeting spot.
  • Ship the car empty. Carriers cannot transport household goods, and items left in the car are not covered.
  • Verify the company. Ask for USDOT and MC numbers and check them with the FMCSA. Here is how to verify a car shipping company.

Get Your Florida Shipping Price

The best way to compare is with your real numbers. Enter your pickup and delivery ZIP codes and your vehicle to see an estimated price range for shipping your car to Florida this winter.

Get your instant quote and decide in minutes whether shipping beats the drive.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to ship my car to Florida or take the Auto Train?

It depends on your dates, how many people are traveling and whether you book a sleeping room. The Auto Train charges for the car and each passenger, and peak snowbird dates cost the most. Shipping from New York to South Florida usually runs about $900 to $1,600 for a sedan on an open carrier, plus your flight. Compare current Auto Train fares for your dates against a shipping quote for your exact route.

Where does the Auto Train go?

The Auto Train runs between Lorton, Virginia, near Washington, D.C., and Sanford, Florida, near Orlando. It is the only route it serves, so you drive to Lorton and from Sanford to your final destination.

How long does it take to drive from New York to Florida?

New York City to Miami is about 1,280 miles, or roughly 20 hours of driving. Most people split it into 2 or 3 days.

How long does it take to ship a car from New York to Florida?

Usually about 3 to 5 days after pickup, plus a pickup window of 1 to 5 business days. Winter weather in the north can add a day.

Can I ship my car to Florida if I am not there to receive it?

Yes. A friend, neighbor or condo manager can receive the car and sign the Bill of Lading on your behalf. Just let your transport specialist know who will be there.

Ready to Get Your Car Shipping Quote?

Get an instant, accurate quote for your vehicle transport with no hidden fees.

Related Articles

Ship a Car Bought Out of State: How to Get Your New Car Home

Need to ship a car bought out of state? Learn who arranges transport, how to handle title, temp tags and taxes, and what to check at delivery. Plan it here.

More details →
Snowbird Car Shipping Guide 2026-27: Ship Your Car South for Winter

Snowbird car shipping made simple: costs for popular routes to Florida, Arizona and Texas, the best dates to book this winter, and a checklist for shipping your car south.

More details →

Get an instant quote

1
2
3
DestinationVehicle InfoContact Details